Search this question and you'll find plenty of broker websites telling you brokers are worth it, which is exactly why so many people add "reddit" to the search instead. They want an unfiltered answer from people who've actually been through it, not a sales pitch. Here's what that unfiltered answer actually looks like, based on genuine borrower discussions, along with the practical detail behind it.
Get Your Free Assessment
The Main Reason People Recommend Using a Broker
Across genuine borrower discussions, the same reason comes up more than any other: a broker compares options across a panel of lenders, rather than you having to approach several banks yourself and compare their offers manually. One frequently cited first-time buyer account described a broker helping them get a lower rate and avoiding a costly insurance requirement they hadn't known about, simply because the broker knew what to check for. That kind of practical, behind-the-scenes knowledge is what people are usually pointing to when they say a broker was worth using.
A broker comparing your options across a panel of lenders is not the same as a whole-of-market comparison. It's worth asking what panel a broker works from before assuming it covers every lender.
What a Broker Actually Does for You
Beyond comparing rates, a broker's day-to-day role usually covers:
- Comparing loan products across their panel of lenders based on your situation
- Explaining costs and conditions you might not think to ask about, such as lenders mortgage insurance
- Preparing and lodging your application, and liaising with the lender on your behalf
- Being a single point of contact if something in your situation is non-standard, such as self-employment or a smaller deposit
How much of this you need depends on your situation. Straightforward applications may need less hand-holding than more complex ones, but the comparison and paperwork support tends to be useful either way.
When a Broker Makes the Most Sense
A broker can be useful for almost anyone, but the value tends to be clearest for first home buyers who haven't been through the process before, self-employed borrowers or anyone with non-standard income, and buyers who simply don't have time to approach multiple lenders themselves. If your situation is straightforward and you're comfortable comparing products yourself, going direct to a bank is a reasonable option too. Neither path is automatically right for everyone.
Not every broker works from the same lender panel, and commission structures can vary. It's reasonable to ask any broker you're considering how they're paid and which lenders they have access to.
The Trade-offs Worth Knowing About
It's a fair question to ask why someone might choose NOT to use a broker too, and genuine discussions on this topic raise a few honest criticisms alongside the praise.
- Compares multiple lenders on one panel instead of a single bank's own products
- Generally paid by the lender, not an upfront fee to you
- Can flag costs and conditions (like LMI) that are easy to miss on your own
- Only compares lenders on that broker's panel, not literally every lender in the market
- Some brokers may lean toward lenders that pay higher commissions rather than genuinely comparing every option on their panel, which is the main reason some people choose to deal with a bank directly instead
- Going direct to one bank means a simpler process, if you're comfortable comparing rates yourself
Thinking About Using a Mortgage Broker?
See how our home loan comparison and application support works.
See how we can help →Frequently Asked Questions
A broker compares home loan options across a panel of lenders rather than one bank's own products, and generally manages much of the paperwork and liaison with the lender for you. Going direct to one bank means you only see that bank's own range.
Not automatically. The rate you're offered depends mainly on your circumstances and the lender's current offers, not which channel you use. A broker's real advantage is being able to compare multiple lenders on their panel in one process, rather than approaching several banks yourself one at a time.
Most brokers, including DFS, are paid a commission by the lender once a loan settles, not a fee charged to you directly. It's reasonable to ask any broker how they're paid and which lenders they work with before deciding whether to proceed.
Want a Second Opinion on Your Options?
Book a free, no-obligation call and we'll walk through what a broker could do for your situation.
Book Free CallNo obligation. We respond within 1 business day.